Skip to main content

Table. 1 Studies reporting optical quality outcomes of eyes implanted with the ICL V4c model using different devices

From: In vivo optical quality of posterior-chamber phakic implantable collamer lenses with a central port

Authors

Year

Eyes (patients)

Follow-up

SE (D)

Device

Shimizu et al. [8]

2012

29 (29)

3 mo

−7.52 ± 2.02

KR-9000(Topcon, Tokyo, Japan)

Hosny and Shalaby [9]

2013

20 (NR)

1.5 mo

−12.9 ± 2.38

ViSX Wavescan(Johnson & Johnson Vision, Jacksonville, USA)

Kamiya et al. [10]

2014

28 (28)

3 mo

−7.17 ± 1.98

OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

Huseynova et al. [11]

2014

44 (44)

3 mo

−10.05 ± 2.72

KR-1 W (Topcon, Tokyo, Japan)

Tian et al. [12]

2017

18 (18)

1 mo

−11.44 ± 5.18

iTrace (Tracey Technologies, Houston, USA)

Park et al. [13]a

2017

46 (28)

3 mo

−8.58 ± 2.08

KR-1 W (Topcon, Tokyo, Japan)OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

Miao et al. [14]

2018

67 (38)

3 mo

−12.44 ± 3.15

OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

Liu et al. [15]

2018

40 (22)

3 mo

−6.12 ± 2.19

ViSX Wavescan(Johnson & Johnson Vision, Jacksonville, USA)OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

Qin et al. [16]

2019

30 (15)

3 mo

−13.87 ± 2.16

iTrace (Tracey Technologies, Houston, USA)

Wan et al. [17]b

2020

27 (27)29 (29)54 (54)27 (27)

6 mo

−5.33 ± 0.83−8.01 ± 0.82−10.67 ± 0.94− 14.01 ± 1.47

WASCA (Carl Zeiss Meditec AG, Jena, Germany)

Niu et al. [18]

2020

39 (20)

12 mo

−7.54 ± 1.07

OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

Wei et al. [19]

2020

94 (57)

6 mo

−8.07 ± 1.03

WASCA (Carl Zeiss Meditec AG, Jena, Germany)

Wei et al. [20]c

2020

42 (21)46 (23)

6 mo

−8.26 ± 1.43− 8.30 ± 1.43

WASCA (Carl Zeiss Meditec AG, Jena, Germany)

Zhang et al. [21]

2020

16 (8)

6 mo

−4.26 ± 1.55

OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

Baptista et al. [22]

2020

30 (15)

38.5 mo

−8.25 ± 2.6

OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

Chen et al. [23]

2021

59 (59)

1 week

−15.16 ± 4.77

OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

Aruma et al. [24]

2021

32 (20)

12 mo

−5.21 ± 0.73

WASCA (Carl Zeiss Meditec AG, Jena, Germany)OQAS (Keeler, Malvern, USA)

  1. SE spherical equivalent; D diopters; NR not reported; mo months
  2. a: data on centered lenses; b: data of 4 subgroups with SE ≤ 6.0 D, SE from −6.13 to −9.0 D, SE from − 9.13 to −12.0 D and SE from − 12.13 to 18.0 D (from top to bottom); c: data of 2 subgroups of non-toric (top) and toric lenses (bottom)